The email from the public school principal arrived in March. My son had been accepted for first grade starting in September. After three years in his beloved Montessori classroom, he would be transitioning to traditional school. I felt simultaneously relieved (no more tuition payments!) and terrified (how would he possibly adapt?).
That first month was harder than I expected, but not in the ways I anticipated. He wasn’t struggling academically. He was struggling with asking permission to use the bathroom, sitting still during long lessons, and understanding why everyone had to do the same worksheet at the same time. Six months later, he’s thriving. But getting there required understanding what this transition actually involves and how to support it effectively.
What You Need to Know
Most Montessori children transition successfully to traditional schools, often excelling academically. Research tracking 400 students over ten years found that children who attended Montessori through fifth grade outperformed peers in math and science and graduated with higher GPAs. The transition isn’t always smooth, but the skills Montessori children develop—independence, problem-solving, love of learning—serve them well in any setting.
- Good News: Children typically adjust within 2-3 months
- Common Challenges: Sitting still, asking permission, homework, grades, less choice
- Biggest Strengths: Independent learning, problem-solving, adaptability
- Timeline: Start preparing 3-6 months before the transition
- Parent Role: Your support and understanding matter enormously
What Actually Changes (And Why It Matters)
Before we talk about how to manage the transition, let’s be honest about what’s different. Your child is moving between two fundamentally different educational philosophies.
For three years, my son chose his own work during three-hour uninterrupted periods. He moved freely around the classroom, used the bathroom when needed, ate snack when hungry. He worked at his own pace, sometimes spending days on one concept, breezing through another in an afternoon. Teachers observed and guided but rarely directed.
Then suddenly, desks in rows, everyone doing the same thing at the same time, 45-minute periods with bells, raising hands for bathroom permission, homework every night, grades on papers. Not better or worse, just completely different. Understanding these specific changes helps you prepare your child.
The Surprising Research About This Transition
When I was drowning in worry about this transition, a friend sent me a research study that changed my perspective completely.
Between 1997 and 2007, researchers supported by the Association Montessori Internationale tracked 400 students in Milwaukee. Half received only public school education from kindergarten through graduation. The other half attended Montessori schools through fifth grade before transitioning to public school. The groups were carefully matched for gender, ethnicity, and family income.
The results? Children who had Montessori education didn’t just transition successfully. They outperformed their peers who had only attended traditional school. The Montessori students scored higher in math and science and graduated with better GPAs. Years after leaving Montessori, the foundation it built continued serving them.
What This Actually Means
The transition might be bumpy for a few months. Your child might struggle with sitting still, asking permission, or understanding grades. But the skills they developed in Montessori—independent thinking, problem-solving, love of learning—don’t disappear. They become advantages once your child adjusts to the new format.
The First Month: What Actually Happens
Let me paint you a realistic picture of those first few weeks, based on my experience and conversations with dozens of other parents who’ve been through this.
Week One: The Honeymoon
Everything is new and exciting. Your child probably loves the notebooks, the desk with their name on it, meeting new friends. They’re on their best behavior, watching carefully to figure out how this new place works. You might think, “This is going so well! Why was I worried?”
Weeks Two to Four: Reality Sets In
The novelty wears off. Your child starts questioning things. “Why do I have to ask to use the bathroom? Why can’t I keep working on this when I’m interested? Why does everyone have to do the same worksheet?” They might come home exhausted from sitting still all day. Homework battles begin. They might say they’re bored or that the work is too easy or too hard or just different from what they expect.
This is when I panicked. My son asked, almost daily, “Why can’t I just go back to my old school?” His teacher sent a note saying he needed to “work on staying in his seat during lessons.” He was frustrated, I was frustrated, everyone was struggling.
Months Two to Three: Finding Their Rhythm
Gradually, things click. Your child figures out the new system. They make friends, find aspects they enjoy, develop routines. They still might not love everything about traditional school, but they adapt. By three months, most children have adjusted and are functioning successfully in their new environment.
For my son, the turning point came when his teacher recognized his independence as a strength rather than a challenge. She started giving him “choice time” as a reward for completed work, letting him pursue topics that interested him. Once he understood the system and had some autonomy within it, he settled in.
The Specific Challenges Your Child Will Face
Understanding the specific pain points helps you address them proactively rather than reactively.
Challenge #1: Sitting Still
Montessori children are used to moving freely. Sitting in one spot for 30-45 minute lessons feels physically uncomfortable. One teacher told me, “Your Montessori kids always look like they’re going to explode from holding still.” It’s not defiance. It’s genuine physical difficulty after years of freedom of movement.
What Helped Us: I talked to the teacher about allowing my son to stand at his desk occasionally or hold a small fidget. At home, we made sure he got lots of physical activity before and after school. We practiced sitting for increasing periods during summer, making it a game rather than a punishment.
Challenge #2: Asking Permission
“Why do I have to ask to use the bathroom? I just went when I needed to before.” This baffled my son more than anything. The concept of needing permission for basic bodily functions didn’t make sense to a child who’d been trusted with that responsibility for years.
What Helped Us: We reframed it as “letting your teacher know where you are” rather than asking permission. We practiced the hand-raising and waiting at home. I also talked to the teacher, who agreed to nod acknowledgment when he raised his hand rather than making him wait to be called on, which felt more respectful to him.
Challenge #3: Everyone Doing the Same Thing
Group instruction feels inefficient to Montessori children. “Why are we going so slowly? I already understand this. Why can’t I move on?” Or conversely, “This doesn’t make sense yet. Why are we moving to the next thing?” They’re used to working at their own pace, mastering concepts before progressing.
What Helped Us: I explained that traditional classrooms work differently but that didn’t make them wrong, just different. When my son was bored, I suggested he could mentally work ahead or help classmates who were struggling. When he was confused, we worked on concepts at home. I also asked the teacher about enrichment opportunities for advanced work.
Challenge #4: Homework
This was our biggest ongoing struggle. Montessori children complete their work at school during long work periods. Suddenly, 30-60 minutes of additional work at home every night felt overwhelming and pointless. “But I already worked all day at school!”
What Helped Us: We created a consistent homework routine with a healthy snack first, a comfortable workspace, and breaks when needed. I didn’t force him to sit at a desk if he preferred the floor or couch. We started with just 15 minutes, building stamina gradually. When homework seemed excessive, I communicated with the teacher about adjusting the load during the transition period.
Challenge #5: Grades
Montessori children work for mastery and internal satisfaction, not external rewards. Suddenly, letters on papers mean something. Some children become anxious about grades. Others dismiss them as meaningless. Both reactions require parent guidance.
What Helped Us: We emphasized learning over grades. When he got a C, I asked, “Did you learn something?” not “Why wasn’t it an A?” We celebrated effort and improvement, not just high marks. I reminded him that grades measure how well you understand what the teacher taught in the specific way they taught it, not how smart you are or how much you actually know.
How to Prepare Before the Transition
Start preparing several months before the transition. The more groundwork you lay, the smoother the adjustment will be.
3-6 Months Before: Start the Conversation
- Talk honestly about what will be different without making it scary
- Read books about starting at a new school
- If possible, visit the new school, tour classrooms, meet teachers
- Connect with other parents whose children made this transition
- Let your child express feelings, concerns, excitement, worries
Summer Before: Practice New Skills
- Practice sitting at a desk or table for longer periods
- Work on asking permission before getting up or getting something
- Do some workbook pages or worksheets to familiarize with the format
- Practice raising hand and waiting to be called on
- Establish a routine that includes homework time
- If possible, arrange playdates with future classmates
First Week: Gather Information
- Attend all orientation sessions, back-to-school nights
- Introduce yourself to the teacher, briefly mention Montessori background
- Ask about classroom expectations, homework policies, grading
- Request email updates or check-ins during the first month
- Join parent organizations to connect with other families
What to Tell Your Child’s New Teacher
How you communicate about your child’s Montessori background matters. You want to inform without seeming defensive or superior.
I sent an email to my son’s teacher before school started. I kept it brief, positive, and solution-focused. I explained that he’d been in Montessori for three years, which meant he was very independent and used to choosing his own work. I mentioned he might need reminders about classroom procedures like raising his hand or staying seated, not because he was misbehaving but because those expectations were new to him.
I asked if she had experience with students transitioning from Montessori and if she had suggestions for supporting the adjustment. I emphasized that I wanted to work as partners to make this successful. This approach positioned me as collaborative rather than difficult, and she responded positively.
What Not to Say
Avoid making Montessori sound superior or suggesting the teacher’s methods are inferior. Don’t say, “He’s used to being treated with respect” (implying traditional schools don’t respect children) or “He won’t understand why everyone has to do the same thing” (implying it’s illogical).
Instead, focus on practical information: “He’s used to choosing his work, so he may need guidance understanding assigned tasks” or “He’s accustomed to moving freely during work time, so sitting for longer periods might be an adjustment.”
Supporting Your Child Through the Transition
Your role during this transition is to provide stability, understanding, and practical support without overreacting to every bump.
Listen Without Fixing
When your child complains about the new school, resist the urge to immediately solve every problem or defend the Montessori approach. Listen. Validate feelings. “It sounds really frustrating to have to ask permission to use the bathroom when you’re used to just going.” Sometimes they just need to vent.
After listening, you can problem-solve together. “What do you think might make this easier?” Often children have good ideas themselves. And if they don’t, you can offer suggestions: “Would it help to go at recess so you don’t have to interrupt class?”
Maintain Montessori Principles at Home
Just because school is different doesn’t mean you abandon what worked. At home, continue giving your child independence, choices, and responsibility. Let them help with cooking, manage their own morning routine, choose how to spend free time. This consistency provides stability when school feels restrictive.
We continued practical life activities at home—my son still set the table, made his lunch, organized his backpack. These familiar tasks grounded him when everything else felt new and different.
Don’t Criticize the New School
It’s tempting to agree when your child complains: “I know, it’s ridiculous that they make you raise your hand!” But criticizing the new school makes adjustment harder. Your child needs to accept and adapt to these new expectations, which is difficult if you’re undermining them.
Instead, acknowledge feelings without judgment: “The rules are different here. All schools have different ways of doing things. What are some things you like about your new school?” Help them find positives alongside the frustrations.
Communicate Regularly with the Teacher
Check in weekly for the first month, then less frequently. Ask specific questions: “How is he doing with sitting during lessons? Is homework completion a problem? How is he socially?” Share what you’re seeing at home. This partnership approach helps you address issues before they become major problems.
When my son’s teacher mentioned he was having trouble finishing work in the allotted time, we realized he was so used to deep focus that he struggled with time limits. Together, we created strategies, a visual timer, breaking tasks into smaller chunks, practicing timed activities at home.
The Unexpected Advantages
Once the dust settled, I started noticing ways Montessori had actually prepared my son beautifully for this new environment.
He knew how to learn independently. When he didn’t understand something, he looked for resources, asked questions, figured it out. Other kids waited for the teacher to re-explain. He advocated for himself. When something wasn’t working, he could articulate what he needed. Other kids just struggled silently.
He had genuine curiosity about learning, not just grades. When a topic interested him, he’d research beyond the assignment. He managed his time well. Years of choosing his own work taught him to budget time and prioritize. He helped classmates naturally, having spent years as both younger and older child in mixed-age classes.
What Teachers Notice About Montessori Students
Traditional school teachers often comment that former Montessori students are more independent, ask better questions, manage their work effectively, help other students generously, and think creatively about problems. Yes, they might struggle with sitting still initially. But their underlying skills are strong.
When to Worry (And When Not To)
Some adjustment challenges are normal. Some signal a problem needing attention. Here’s how to tell the difference.
Normal (Don’t Panic)
- Complaining about rules or structure for first 1-2 months
- Needing reminders about classroom procedures
- Taking time to make new friends (up to 3 months)
- Being bored with some lessons that review familiar concepts
- Struggling with sitting still initially
- Homework battles while establishing routines
- Occasional frustration or sadness about missing old school
Concerning (Talk to Teacher and Consider Support)
- Refusing to go to school persistently after first month
- Significant behavior problems (acting out, defiance) beyond month two
- Complete social isolation after three months
- Anxiety or depression that wasn’t present before
- Dramatic drop in confidence or self-esteem
- Academic struggles across multiple subjects that persist
- Physical symptoms (stomachaches, headaches) related to school
Most children adjust successfully within three months. If your child is still significantly struggling after that point, it’s worth having deeper conversations with teachers, possibly considering whether this particular school is the right fit, or seeking support from a counselor who can help with the transition.
The Questions Parents Always Ask
These questions came up repeatedly in parent support groups during our transition year.
Will my child be behind academically?
+
Unlikely. Your child might be ahead in some areas, behind in others, depending on what they chose to focus on in Montessori. They might need to learn specific formats (how your school teaches long division, for example) but they have the underlying understanding. More importantly, they know how to learn, which means they can catch up quickly in any area where they need to.
Should I tell my child traditional school is inferior to Montessori?
+
Absolutely not. This makes adjustment much harder. Traditional school isn’t worse, it’s different. Both approaches have strengths. Present it positively: “You learned so much in Montessori, and now you’ll experience a different way of learning. Both are valuable.” Help your child see benefits of the new environment rather than just losses from the old one.
How can I help with homework when I disagree with how they’re teaching?
+
Help your child complete the homework in the way the teacher expects, even if you’d teach it differently. Your child needs to learn what their current teacher wants. At home, you can supplement with approaches that make more sense to you, but don’t confuse them by contradicting what they’re learning at school. Pick your battles. Most concepts can be understood multiple ways.
What if my child is genuinely miserable months into the transition?
+
Give it three months before making major decisions. If after that time your child is still deeply unhappy, consider whether it’s the specific school or traditional education in general that’s the issue. Visit the classroom, talk extensively with teachers, possibly consult with a counselor. Some children do better in alternative settings. Some schools are better than others at supporting diverse learners. It’s okay to acknowledge that this particular situation isn’t working and explore other options.
Trust the Foundation You Built
A year after that terrifying transition, my son is thriving. He’s on the honor roll, has good friends, plays on a sports team, and generally enjoys school. More importantly, he still loves learning. He still asks questions, pursues interests, and thinks independently. The Montessori foundation didn’t disappear just because the environment changed.
What surprised me most is that he found aspects of traditional school he actually prefers. He likes being part of a team all working toward the same goal. He enjoys the structured schedule that makes days predictable. He appreciates having friends all the same age who share similar interests and abilities.
The transition wasn’t easy. Those first months were genuinely hard for all of us. But children are remarkably adaptable. The skills Montessori built, independence, problem-solving, love of learning, confidence, don’t disappear. They become advantages once your child figures out how to apply them in this new context.
Trust the foundation you built during those Montessori years. Give your child time to adjust. Provide support without rescuing. Communicate with teachers without being defensive. And know that research backs up what I’ve experienced: children who received Montessori education bring real strengths to traditional schools. They just need a little time to translate those strengths into this new language.
Sources & References
- Dohrmann, K. R., Nishida, T. K., Gartner, A., Lipsky, D. K., & Grimm, K. J. (2007). High school outcomes for students in a public Montessori program. Journal of Research in Childhood Education, 22(2), 205-217. DOI: 10.1080/02568540709594622
- Association Montessori Internationale USA. (2012). Outcomes Study: Milwaukee Public Schools Montessori Program. Retrieved from https://amiusa.org
- Lillard, A. S. (2017). Montessori: The Science Behind the Genius (3rd ed.). Oxford University Press. DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190613976.001.0001
- Rathunde, K., & Csikszentmihalyi, M. (2005). Middle school students’ motivation and quality of experience: A comparison of Montessori and traditional school environments. American Journal of Education, 111(3), 341-371. DOI: 10.1086/428885
- American Montessori Society. (2024). Transitioning from Montessori Programs. Retrieved from https://amshq.org
- Seldin, T., & Epstein, P. (2006). The Montessori Way. Montessori Foundation.